Fatherland (2026): ‘What is Tomorrow Worth, in Light of the Bleakness of Today?’
Fatherland (2026) follows Thomas Mann (Hanns Zischler), a repatriated self-exile, and his daughter, Erika (Sandra Hüller), across the post-WWII German landscape as they travel to accept the Goethe Prize. Partially fictionalised from the account of real-life author Thomas Mann, the film explores global cultural and ideological divides and their parallel impacts on the domestic serenity of family. In a turbulent country, operating in an anarchical world system, how does the struggle to navigate personal and familial identity mirror the struggle to reconcile oneself with their country? What are the ties between belonging and legacy?
Thomas Mann, a German novelist and Nobel Laureate, fled to Switzerland after Hitler’s rise to power in 1933, and then later to the USA, where he became a citizen and dedicated his time to recording monthly anti-Nazi broadcasts. Shortly after the end of WWII, Mann delivered this moving speech about the disconnect between individual power and German collective guilt:
“Those who, a long time ago, imagined during sleepless nights how terrible would be the revenge on Germany for the inhuman deeds of the Nazis, cannot help but view all that is being done to Germans as nothing other than a mechanical and inevitable reaction to the crimes that the people have committed as a nation, in which unfortunately the guilt or innocence of the individual can play no part.”
Following his self-exile, Mann never lived in Germany again despite travelling there many times. His most important visit, which Fatherland centres on, is his journey in 1949 during the anniversary of Johann Wolfgang von Goethe, attending celebrations in Frankfurt am Main (West Germany) and Weimar (East Germany), as a statement that German culture and connection extend beyond political borders.
Pawlikowski echoes this sentiment in Fatherland - interweaving the personal and the political to create a gripping solemnity that attributes modern pains to unanswered historical trauma - all to answer the question “What is tomorrow worth, in light of the bleakness of today?”
Pawel Pawlikowski is a Polish-born director, critically acclaimed for his films ‘Last Resort’ (2000), ‘Ida’ (2013), and ‘Cold War’ (2018) – the second of which won during the 87th Academy Awards for the Best International Feature Film. Much of Pawlikowski’s work is characterised by complex family dynamics and a commitment to authenticity despite working in fiction. Pawlikowski uses his filmography to explore immigration, suffering, nationalism, and other thematic concepts of guilt and pain, as well as broader socio-political implications on domestic life. His films are often praised for their poetic cinematography and engaging yet minimal dialogue.
In Fatherland, which debuted at Cannes Film Festival 2026, Pawlikowski draws on his lived experience between the UK and Poland to inform his characters’ cultural depth and to portray the Zeitgeist of 1940s Germany, particularly the conflict between a communist-socialist East and the capitalist West.
Recently, I had the pleasure of viewing Fatherland at Hyde Park Picture House and was overwhelmed to witness the popularity of the film with only two seats left unoccupied in the whole screening. Whilst I can’t attest to the rest of the audience’s opinion, I think the minutes of silence following the production credits speak volumes to the impact this film had, and, personally, I was blown away by the masterful intertwining of grief and pride.
Whilst Pawlikowski’s work follows a pattern of dramatic constraint, the substance and emotional catharsis remain rich, which is especially true of Fatherland. Thomas and Erika’s melancholy trip through a torn Germany encapsulates their search to find meaning and belonging amidst a ravaged country - a journey which Pawlikowski uses to warn against recklessly aligning oneself with a public symbol without any willingness to morally commit.
This film, shot in greyscale, illuminates the direct link between cinema and artistry and expands on the director’s interest in post-WWII suffering – stylistically displayed in his previous films. Its bisected geographical structure serves to highlight the divisive experience that survivors fought as they came to grips with a new, emerging world order, so different from the one of yesterday. Similarly, Erika’s unsteady paternal bond is also metaphorically portrayed through the bisection, as Thomas considers the existential uncertainty of where we belong, fostering distance between himself and his children.
The technical use of greyscale and the absence of colour evokes the hopelessness endured in the years following the fall of the Nazi Party, and the desperation to regain reputation and recognition of the German people on an international stage. This intensity of light and contrasts between the shades of grey symbolises death to the old ways of thinking, and both the remorse of the past and the fear of the future, reminiscent of European post-war regret - completing this muted feeling of mournfulness and paralysed psyche, stuck in the heaviness of the past whilst yearning for a future. The double entendre of the title – “Fatherland” – captures this succinctly, relating to both Thomas’ connection to his family roots through the suffering on his home soil under Nazi rule, and his connection to his family through his responsibility as a father.
Both the performances and the cinematography relay a quiet repression, which, at first, makes it seemingly tough to connect with the characters, particularly with Thomas Mann, who, first and foremost, is presented as self-involved and passionately distanced from any form of personal relationship. Hanns Zischler’s acting is the key ingredient to perfecting such a complex character, and his contribution cannot be overstated. Whilst many actors would dismiss Mann as cold or bitter, Zischler outperforms all expectations to construct a layered approach to a subdued and misunderstood man, who hides exhaustion behind his poetic speeches.
As the film progresses, the multifaceted layers to Mann are peeled away, leaving the shell of a grieving father with a declining national faith and uncertainty for the future of his family and his home. This culminates in a quiet, yet spiritually striking final scene, where the audience, at last, experiences the depth of Mann’s emotional suppression as he breaks down beside his daughter and loses the collected composure that has been slowly chipped away throughout the whole film.
The same is true of Sandra Hüller, who plays Erika Mann, and is illustrated to be the foil of her father. Erika’s similarities to her father are undeniable; both are supremely intelligent and respected individuals whose actions are characterised by simultaneously a defiance against the erasure of the past and a perseverance for the future, even in the face of personal loss. However, whereas Zischler’s character is stubbornly self-reliant, creating isolation from the audience, Hüller’s character may be marginally easier to relate to, depicted through the bond she shares with her brother, Klaus – played by August Diehl. He leaves a lasting impression with his first and only one-take scene, and his unexpected suicide profoundly shapes the film’s memory and events. This sibling dynamic grants the audience an insight into the depth of Erika’s compassion and loyalty to her family, something missing from Mann’s initial characterisation.
Hüller’s ability to transform a script into an entrancing rendition of human strength and fallibility underscores the messaging of Pawlikowski’s direction – how the differences of past, present, and future can appear monumental but the similarities much more significant, especially as generations stand side by side through mutual suffering and change.
It is possible that this film, because of its haunting albeit restricted emotionalism, is not to everyone’s taste – particularly if you are unfamiliar with Pawlikowski's style and this is your introduction to his exploration of ideological entrapment. Therefore, I would recommend viewing both ‘Ida’ and ‘Cold War’ prior to this, in order to develop an understanding of the political context informing these screenplays and to get the most feeling out of Pawlikowski’s post-war trilogy pieces.
Yet overall, I thoroughly enjoyed Fatherland and found the production choice, as well as the artistic expression, to be cinematically unique. The 82-minute length is deceptively short for what turns out to be an overwhelmingly precise film. Pawlikowski truly masters the ability to enforce the quiet, lingering sense of despair without a need for dramatics or an unnecessarily elongated runtime. Without a doubt, I recommend adding this to your watchlist.
Words by Chloe Hayes, she/her
.jpg)

Comments