top of page

Everyone Wants to be a Gay Icon, but Where are the Gay Popstars?

11 minutes ago
4 min read

Pop music, for decades, has established an incredible connection with the queer community. Many of the most popular female popstars, such as Madonna, Cher, or Lady Gaga, are commonly recognised and labelled as ‘gay icons’ by their fans. This has now transformed into a coveted title for popstars; it displays a different level of cool and prestige. It demonstrates how they have their finger on the pulse of something different, queer, and exciting. Stereotypically, and in my own experience, gay men adore their favourite female stars and are incredibly embroiled in the goings-on in the pop music zeitgeist, so why are there so few gay popstars right now?


As much as these icons resonate with me, I feel like in pop music we are always the consumer, and do not have an active role in the modern pop market. I often see artists who have never been seen to be gay icons suddenly and inorganically turn their aesthetic to cater to and, accidentally parody, what the ‘gay pop’ scene wants. I’ve seen artists such as Megan Trainor turn around and attempt a glitzy, wannabe-camp, dance-pop song surrounded by all the things a label executive thinks would fire the synapses in a gay man’s brain and be called a ‘gag’. 


Of course, there have been and still are gay pop stars such as Elton John, George Michael and more recently, Troye Sivan. However, to me, modern pop has very few gay male or even queer artists in any form that have succeeded in becoming true chart-topping, arena-selling popstars. For me, this lack of diversity in pop right now is troubling. As a genre, pop music is more than just catchy songs; it displays what’s prevalent in our culture and even politics. The changes in sounds, trends, and demographics align with changes in governments, economies, and general online conversations. So, to me, the lack of gay male popstars is alarming, as we are in an era where the manosphere has become widespread, and right-wing rhetoric becomes increasingly popular with each passing day.


I’ve seen not just a lack of gay popstars, but also a general distaste for this subversion of traditional masculinity through the response to our queer pop artists. Lil Nas X, for example, was positioned in 2019 to be one of the next big things. At the start of his career, he had an impressive run of singles, but suddenly, as he began to incorporate male love interests in music videos and embrace a visual queerness, I began to see homophobic online conversation about him. Slowly, he began to fall out of our current consciousness. The other popular gay male pop musicians I can think of, such as Omar Apollo, Conan Gray, or Orville Peck, have made a decent name for themselves in mainstream culture, but they have never succeeded in creating a big hit song or truly rising to the level their straight counterparts have.


I know that the pop sphere holds every artist in a precarious place, where one misstep in the public eye or a song that doesn't fulfil particular expectations can knock an artist from being the next big thing to falling from people’s thoughts completely. This frustration has become more apparent due to the rise of obviously manufactured stars, and songs pushed on TikTok and Spotify. My gay friends and I find it peculiar that there are an incredibly small number of gay men in pop who have succeeded in becoming chart-topping sensations. It always feels like the loud, queer artists are the ones to take the brunt of these digital witch hunts.


Even Troye Sivan has recently been subjected to homophobic conversation online about his songs that proudly express his sexuality too much, and it being the dominant feature of his brand. This only makes me question: why can’t being gay be his brand? I personally see this response to his artistry and aesthetics as a development of the bigoted argument that gay people “shove their sexuality in other people’s faces”. Is the reason why we have so few gay popstars because just announcing your queerness and being openly untraditional in your masculinity is too much for audiences? The topics Sivan sings about are mostly not specific to one sexuality, so why is the difference in who he’s addressing off-putting to someone? Does the supposed problem lie in the fact he’s active in writing about his queerness?


We have a decent number of male musicians who are openly straight or choose to not name their sexuality, such as Harry Styles or Sombr. These artists are less traditionally masculine than expected. For example, in 2020 Harry Styles was praised for wearing dresses, but as his career has progressed and the political climate has changed, he has lessened this queer-adjacent aesthetic in his work. So, to me, there is space for male artists who subvert the typical idea of manliness, but this can only be at a surface level, and queer artists who may express themselves in a similar way are instead rejected by audiences. 


Gay men are pretty well represented in TV and Film, at least in comparison to the rest of the LGBTQ community, so why are there so few gay male popstars in comparison? Maybe it’s due to the fact that these queer characters on the screen are often written and created by straight producers, such as Heated Rivalry’s author being a straight woman, usually for straight audiences to be the main consumers. Maybe it’s because these gay characters are just characters; mostly surface-level in shaping their identity or lacking in stakes to their art. I personally find it troubling that in an age of rising bigotry towards the entire LGBTQ community, queer people are only accepted in the media as often reductive characters. Are these gay popstars too ‘in our face’ and real to be good products to sell to the masses? Is this another sign that the general public’s opinions towards queer people as a whole are souring even further?  


To me, the absence of gay popstars signifies more than just what’s going on in our music industry. Since the start of the decade, homophobia and toxic masculinity have been rising rapidly, and this societal reluctance to embrace a gay popstar shows a horrifying direction for our culture. As a gay man, I am frustrated and worried that we are often used as a marketing strategy or accessory to give a subversive, trendy aspect to an artist, while not having our own voice in this industry, and what this means for more than just our music.


Words by George Armstrong, hey/they






Recent Posts

See All
An Ode to Not Figuring Everything Out

I’m penniless and pleasantly spirited, and I’m sure there's a bottle of wine and half a block of cheese in my fridge, and only currently that is customary. It’s bordering on sensible to still believe

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page